Copyright Trolls Sue Thoughts From A Conservative Mom

Some of you may already be aware that on April 1st, I was served with papers to inform me that I and my blog are being sued for alleged copyright infringement because of an image on my blog that I thought was public domain.

Righthaven is a legal group which apparently purchases the rights to news content and images for the explicit purpose of filing lawsuits, banking on the fact that their targets (mostly bloggers and non-profits) can’t afford to hire a lawyer to defend themselves, and using the threat of litigation to extract settlements from their victims.   Though my contact info is readily available on my blog, Righthaven never bothered to issue a warning or a cease and desist letter, and I wasn’t even aware that I was being sued until a reporter from the Las Vegas Sun, Steve Green, contacted me for comment.  He has been covering the story of  for a year, and told me that his contacting them for comment is usually the first indication that any of Righthaven’s victims have that they are even being targeted.  He included my comments in a recent story.

I Googled Righthaven and thousands of hits came up.  They’ve got quite a track record:

Righthaven Victims: A website that lists the victims of Righthaven LLC ‘shakedown’ lawsuits that are causing irreparable harm to bloggers and advocacy websites

Righthaven’s Brand of Copyright Trolling

Bloggers vs. Righthaven

EFF Decries ‘Sham’ Copyright-Troll Legal Tactics

Righthaven lawsuits backfire, reduce protections for newspapers

I cannot discuss the details of the case, except to say that I have manged to hired a lawyer through a Pre-Paid Legal Service our family subscribed to some time ago (my husband’s industry is highly litigious), and intend to fight these extortionists.   Thankfully, it appears that the courts are on to their game.

In his statement refusing a time extension request from Righthaven, Judge John L Kane of the Federal Court of the District of Colorado issued this stinging rebuke:

“the courts are not merely tools for encouraging and exacting settlements from Defendants cowed by the potential costs of litigation and liability.”

Recent developments also suggest that Righthaven’s entire operation may be unraveling:

Why Righthaven’s Copyright Assignment Is A Sham – And Why It Matters

Is Righthaven about to get some payback?

Righthaven Turnover Rate Resembles Fast Food Chain Operation

The Righthaven Website is Gone — Redirected, Perhaps to Hades or Beyond?

In the meantime, I still have to defend myself against these trolls, so please pray for wisdom, justice and protection for my family.  It’s so sad that our legal system has been so corrupted that it can be abused and exploited by such disgusting opportunists.


UPDATE: The Las Vegas Sun mentions my blog in their latest report on Righthaven.

UPDATE:  The New York Times has picked up the story and quotes me in the second half.


If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

3 thoughts on “Copyright Trolls Sue Thoughts From A Conservative Mom”

  1. Wow. I, too, missed you during Lent. This is just hard to believe… well, almost – if I didn’t realize what kind of society we’re living in! Praying for you!

  2. Thanks everyone for your support! It cost us everything in our savings to pay the retainer fee for the lawyer. That was all we had laid aside as an emergency fund to pay doctor’s bills (we don’t have insurance) and cover expenses in case of a job loss or something else. Please pray that God protects us from any unexpected expenses, that the case is settled quickly in our favor, and that we are able to get our money back.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *